Subject: Ohio's gun laws
being challenged by four workers
Goal:
OK to carry concealed weapon:
A hairdresser, a personal
trainer, a delivery man and a private investigator will ask a judge today to let
them carry guns on the job. All four are part of a Hamilton County lawsuit that
was filed Monday in hopes of overturning Ohio's concealed weapons law. The
lawsuit argues that the law is unconstitutional because it does not distinguish
between criminals and people who carry guns for their own protection.
"We're trying to get the attention of the state legislature," said
Chuck Klein, a Cincinnati private investigator who is part of the lawsuit.
"If they don't want us
to carry guns, they've got to change the Constitution to stop us." His
attorney, Tim Smith and William Gustavson, will ask Judge Robert Ruehlman to
issue an order today allowing Mr. Klein and the others to carry guns on the job.
They say their clients need the guns because they are physically unable to
defend themselves or because they keep large amounts of cash with them. The
lawyers also have asked for a trial date so they can argue for throwing out the
concealed weapons law altogether.
They argue that the law is
unfair because it conflicts with the Ohio and US constitutions. On one hand,
they say, Ohio's Constitution allows carrying a gun to protect life and
property. On the other, state law bars people from carrying a concealed weapon
under any circumstances. Mr. Klein said the only way a person can find out if he
is breaking the law is to get arrested, go to court and hope a judge finds in
his favor. "That's totally unfair," Mr. Klein said.
The same argument came up
in May when a pizza delivery man, Patrick Feely, won the right to carry a gun
for protection. The lawsuit names Hamilton County Sheriff Simon L. Leis and
Cincinnati Police Chief Thomas Streicher as defendants because they are
responsible for enforcing the law. City attorneys say they will argue that the
state law is a proper way to protect police and citizens. "There is no
fundamental constitution right to carry a concealed weapon," said Richard
Ganulin, an assistant city solicitor.
Judge Ruehlman will decide
today whether the four people who filed the lawsuit should be allowed to carry
guns pending a trial. Judge Ruehlman already has ruled on one major case
involving gun control. Last year, he threw out the city of Cincinnati's lawsuit
against gun manufacturers. The judge said the misuse of firearms is beyond the
control of gun maker.
Quote -- One would be in
less danger from the wiles of a stranger if one's own kin and kith were more fun
to be with -- Ogden Nash.
|